“Keeping CCTV In Its Place” 3

Michael Minieri
Michael Minieri

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Michael Minieri is the Principal Security Consultant for Minieri Associates, a security consulting and engineering firm operating nationally and internationally. He began a career of protecting lives and property in 1974 and holds nearly a dozen professional credentials. More information can be found at www.minieriassociates.com

Thanks Michael!

We also had Todd Thompson and Travis Chaffin give their takes on the matter.  So make sure you check out their articles after you read this one.  And don’t forget to give us YOUR take!

If Security Cameras Are Not a Deterrent to Crime, Then What Good Are They?  by Todd Thompson

CCTV Misconception by Travis Chaffin

Guest Post by Michael Minieri – Minieri Associates

When most security laymen (and even some security professionals) think to add or increase their physical security measures, CCTV is often the very first thing to come to mind. If CCTV is such an effective security measure, why is it that reality television and the nightly news is so full of CCTV footage of crimes being committed?

Many local governments around the world continue to implement major CCTV systems on city streets and in other public places, frequently with a stated purpose of fighting terrorism. The city of London, for example, has thousands of cameras. It also happens to be the source of one of the most widely circulated CCTV videos of an actual terrorist bombing in history. This incident and others can make a person long for the good ole days of simple convenience store robbery footage!

Worldwide, it is extremely common for the police and others responsible for investigating crimes and apprehending criminals to highly recommend CCTV and to deploy cameras extensively to further THEIR primary objective. CCTV can be an EXCELLENT tool for this purpose! But, private security practitioners are paid to pursue a different objective PREVENTING losses from occurring in the first place.

Certainly, such examples do not imply that CCTV is ineffective as a security tool, but the above examples should clearly illustrate that CCTV  like every other security tool – has practical limitations that must be considered when developing any effective securitysolution. One of the related limitations is among the most commonerrors encountered in security efforts around the globe: Expecting a person to watch one or more monitors and actually detect a crime or other loss at all, much less in sufficient time to prevent it.

Of the six (6) absolutely essential elements of an effective security program, CCTV is probably the very best tool currently available for at least one of those elements. VALIDATION (of the adversarial attack to verify that a response is warranted). Coupled with video analytics, such as video motion detection, CCTV is also the frequent choice for DETECTION (of the adversarial attack such as along a perimeter fence), due to the cost-effective nature of achieving both detection and validation with some of the same investment. By having the video motion feature activate an audible signal at the monitoring position (and displaying the associated camera view automatically), the error of relying on the human to discover the attack through observation is all but eliminated.

3 Comments

  1. I can recommend to always purchase the most high spec cctv camera kit you can afford

    CCTV Camera kits
  2. My frustration with many CCTV system designs is people do not know what they want to achieve and as a result get a result that meets there level of knowledge. One that does not achieve much.

    I wish more people selling CCTV could promote the fundamentals of what a camera is used for. Starting at 4CIF the person need to occupy the below % of the scene height for the following. If you double the resolution, halve the %

    Identify an unknown person 100%
    Recognise a known person 50%
    Detect what a person is doing 10%
    Observe is a person is in an area 5%

  3. Hiya, I’m really glad I have found this info. Today bloggers publish only about gossips and net and this is actually frustrating. A good site with interesting content, that is what I need. Thanks for keeping this website, I will be visiting it. Do you do newsletters? Can not find it.

    Discount voucher

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call Now ButtonCALL NOW TOLL FREE