CCTV Security Systems & Technology
TwitterFacebookYouTube
1-877-926-2288
Video Surveillance Equipment
Request a Quote Today!

Video Compression for DVRs – H.264 vs. M-JPEG & MPEG-4

Most DVRs on the market offer H.264 codec to compress videos.  H.264 records high quality videos while reducing storage space on your Hard Disk Drive (HDD).  To get an idea of how it works, let us compare it to its predecessors.

The two typical video compression formats for DVRs before H.264 were Motion JPEG, or M-JPEG (Joint Photographic Experts Group), and MPEG-4 (Moving Picture Experts Group).  These three compression modes can all display and record up to 30 FPS.  However, there are some areas in which they differ significantly.

 

M-JPEG

M-JPEG is the compilation of separately compressed JPEGs in a sequence, thus creating a video.  It focuses on the quality of the image, rather than the quantity, i.e. less frames per second, and priority is given to image resolution.  This compression is appropriate for megapixel cameras, and many cameras are supported.

Some advantages of M-JPEG include better decompression on the computer, better live viewing, and great image quality (consistently).  M-JPEG is also unlicensed, making it free for the user and viewer.  Another aspect that makes M-JPEG good is its robustness, if one frame is dropped, then it does not affect the video.

The disadvantages of M-JPEG are huge drawbacks, however.  Sound synchronization is not supported.  Due to the high resolution of the images, they take up a lot of space on the HDD, although the image size can be restricted in the settings.  Also because of the size, it requires much more bandwidth to transmit the photos.

 

MPEG-4

MPEG-4 uses techniques similar to M-JPEG, as far as putting pictures in a sequence.  It essentially compares two compressed images, saves the picture, and it saves only the difference from each additional sequential image, such as movement, thus saving time, memory space and processing power.

A higher compression rate is amongst the advantages of MPEG-4.  It can sync audio and video, and is great for real-time viewing.  MPEG-4 was designed to support low-bandwidth applications.

Disadvantages of MPEG-4 include lower picture quality (than M-JPEG), and it is licensed, making a fee a possibility for viewers.  It supports a less number of cameras, such as megapixel cameras.

 

H.264

H.264 is another name given to MPEG-4 Part 10, and is also known as AVC (Advanced Video Coding).  Like MPEG-4, H.264 saves the picture and uses the background for the next few frames, and just records the movement, but with more flexibility.  It compresses the images and reduces the space it takes on the HDD, while preserving the crispness and quality of the image.

H.264 offers higher compression rates, and requires much less storage space than MPEG-4 and M-JPEG.  It supports AV syncing and it is designed for real-time videos.

Some cons of H.264 are low robustness, i.e. if a frame drops because of bandwidth, then the video is affected.  Decompression is a bit high on computers, and live viewing is somewhat delayed.

 

This is our front office, the left being the original image, the center is MPEG4, and the image on the right is H.264.  Notice how it’s there is not much difference in the picture quality, in fact, they’re very similar.  What’s important is the compression, the space you can save by using each video codec.  These pictures were taken with a GeoVision computer-based DVR.

Video Compression Comparison

Video Compression Comparison (left: original; center: MPEG4; right: H.264)

 

Here is a chart portraying the difference in space each compression takes. (image from Axis)

H.264 Video Compression Comparison Line Chart

H.264 Video Compression Comparison Line Chart

 

10 thoughts on “Video Compression for DVRs – H.264 vs. M-JPEG & MPEG-4

  1. Buenos días, tengo este sistema de seguridad y me gustaría saber cómo puedo reproducir los archivos .dat que genera el dvr h264. Me robaron y tengo la grabación pero la guardia civil necesita solo una fracción de tiempo y he de poder reproducirlo en el ordenador.
    He intentado con infinidad de reproductores bajados de internet pero no me funciona ninguno.

    Si fueran tan amables de ayudarme les quedaría muy agradecido.

  2. Please Let me know ASAP
    I try to record specific scene couple of hours. Can u tell the detail.please.
    THANKS!
    URGENT!

  3. Thanks for your write-up. My partner and i have always observed that a majority of people are needing to lose weight since they wish to appear slim along with attractive. Nonetheless, they do not often realize that there are many benefits for losing weight additionally. Doctors assert that obese people suffer from a variety of conditions that can be instantly attributed to their excess weight. The great news is that people who are overweight plus suffering from numerous diseases are able to reduce the severity of their own illnesses by way of losing weight. It is easy to see a constant but noted improvement in health while even a small amount of weight reduction is realized.

  4. I have noticed that online diploma is getting well-known because obtaining your college degree online has developed into a popular solution for many people. Quite a few people have never had an opportunity to attend an established college or university although seek the elevated earning possibilities and a better job that a Bachelor’s Degree gives you. Still others might have a degree in one discipline but would like to pursue some thing they now possess an interest in.

  5. I cant seem to format my H.264 CCTV system through my DVR so system wont record,is there anyway i can format my HHD putting it into H.264 format using windows XP and software so can use on DVR. Thanks

    • Jimmy,

      No you cannot use PC or Mac to format the hard drive of the DVR, because it uses different formatting options than the one your PC uses. Please test the hard drive and make sure it is working properly. Press Menu > Hard Disk > and then click the Format button.

      -Shakib

  6. thanks for the usefull review. ı just want to add that the customers must be very clever, when it comes to the purchasing point. some dealers sell mpeg4 dvr with a price of h.264 dvrs. and does not inform the customer about the storage space, tranmitting speed. costomers should be aware of what they are buying. the price must not the first concern while buying a dvr camera system.

    waiting your new reviews to read, regards..

  7. This is a good example of how different compression algorithms work but I believe there is much more to it.

    You can look at the h.264 from 3 different manufactures, all looking at the same scene and get very different bandwidths and image qualities.
    This is because the h.264 is a tool kit with many tools the choose from. You can use some or all of them but the fact that different vendors use different tools means the results are not the same. The only similarity is the fact they are able to be decompressed as h.264.

    There is a good layman’s post on this here
    http://cctvdesign.com.au/check-the-video-compression-not-all-cameras-have-the-same-image-quality-for-the-same-bandwidth

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>